Shared August 3, 2013
Definitions of the word "Game" are varied, vague, and often useless in any serious discussion of, well, games. But, simultaneously, most people who try to strictly define the word do so primarily to denigrate games or other activities which for whatever reason they do not respect.
"That's not a game; you're not a gamer."
Definitions are important if we want to have real discussions. They provide boundaries and parameters for debate. Role playing games are distinct from competitive games in very profound ways, and it is useful to be able to discuss them separately when appropriate.
At GeekNights, we use three core definitions of game:
1. A competitive test of skills.
2. A series of interesting decisions.
3. An interactive (consensual) amusement.
George Skaff Elias, Richard Garfield, K. and Robert Gutschera, in 'Characteristics of Games,' defined the term "orthogame" in order to largely address the first of these.
Orthogame: A competition between two or more players using an agreed-upon set of rules and a method of ranking.
We use the term "idiogame" to largely cover the second.
Idiogame: A series of interesting decisions that produce a personal outcome.
Role Playing Games are in a sense idiogames, but they are further distinct from other games covered by this definition. Thus:
Role Playing Game: A method of conflict resolutionfor collaborative storytelling.
Scott and I flew to Melbourne, Victoria to lecture at PAX Australia 2013 (the first one)! This is an excerpt from our lecture there: Beyond Dungeons & Dragons.
Ethics in Game Design - PAX Prime 2012
Jedi fight with their lightsabers WRONG: Star Wars
More adventures in replying to spam | James Veitch
Why Do We Play Games?
How Darth Plagueis Had a Terrifying Vision of Darth Vader - Star Wars Explained
The Stupendous Wave
Film Theory: Is SAO the MOST EXPENSIVE GAME EVER? (Sword Art Online)
The Film Theorists
Police Try Playing Grand Theft Auto 5 Without Breaking Any Laws • Pro Play
Co-Stars Who Couldn't Stand Each Other Off Camera
TRY NOT TO LAUGH!! - ONE LINERS & DAD JOKES!
Things only ORIGINAL MINECRAFTERS Remember! #3
Magic Stores Re-Sealing ALL the Pre-Release Kits and Hosing Players
Top 10 Secrets in Zelda: Breath of the Wild